CLICK HERE FOR BLOGGER TEMPLATES AND MYSPACE LAYOUTS »

Thursday, December 13, 2007

which point of view?

there is a big argument over whether books should be written in first person or third person. i, personally, prefer writing stories in first person. but some people say that they don't like the narrator using words like "i" or "me", for some reason that i have yet to figure out.
i think writing in first person makes the story seem more realisitc. instead of some random person telling you a story, the character is actually telling you what happened to him. you connect to the story better. also, it's easier to prtray the character's thoughts and feelings through the character's own words . if you're writing something in third-person, this doesn't always work out very well.
there are, however, two problems with writing in first person. the first problem is that, though you get to know the narrative chracter very well, you don't usually end up knowing the other characters as well as you would in a third person omnicient story. (did i spell the right?)
another problem that arises is that it's very hard to kill off a character when he's the narrator. you know what i mean? it's like "and then all of a sudden, the evil man pulled the trigger and i-"
The End.
that's not a very good ending to a book, now is it?
there is a brilliant solution to these problems, that more and more authors are beginning to use: write in first person AND third person. switch off! if the author is a good writer, this works vey well. take Jonathan Stroud, for example. his books The Bartimaues Trilogy (which i highly recommend you read ASAP) had chapters that kept switching off between the viewpoints of the characters. for many chapters, the story was in first person, as seen through the eyes of the main character, so you got to know him very well. but other chapters were written in third person, so you got the other sides of the story as well.
so, that was a strange and slightly boring discussion, wasn't it? so what do you people think? is it better to write in third or first person?

12 comments:

ImitationRandomFactor said...

imitationrandom factor thinks its better to write in third person. actually, i think its better to write in 3rd person.
HAH! corny! peppery1 tomatoey! (ahh, i'm getting hyper!)
well, to telly u the false truth (they cancel e/o out!) i believe that the P.O.V. depends on the actual piece of literature, before it is written. It depends on the authors decision of how he would prefer to design the story- and this can elaborate on the personal thoughts, or many characters actions.
however, combining this blog w/ a previous one-
it is utterely impossible to produce the same emotional feelings from a story written in 1st person to a movie- the tone would never be the same!
ENYEH!

ImitationRandomFactor said...

griiffinrider, i would appreciate some sort of response immeadiately, in addition to a more interesting blog topic!

griffinrider said...

hey IRF!
everything you're saying is true, especially the part about movies. it's virtually impossible to keep the tone of a book n a movie. that's another good reason why movie versions of books are not a good idea! thanks for your imput. i'm sorry you found this post boring.

griffinrider said...

hey cewkee!
the whole point of this "comments" ting is to , well, LEAVE COMMENTS!! if you don't have comments, you may keep it to yourself. thank you for your cooperation.
ENYEH!!

4evernameless said...

what does enyeh mean?

griffinrider said...

"enyeh" is a letter in the spanish alphabet. it looks like the letter "N", but it has a little squiggly thng on top.

sweetpotatopie said...

what sound does the "N" with the squiggel untop make? i do not know but from where i am "No hablo espanol"

griffinrider said...

Hey, SPP:
if you're interested in spanish, allow me to recommend an incredibly entertaining and informative video called... actually, i don't know what it's called. in fact, i don't even know if it has a title. but if you're interested , you may ask a certain Senorita Lapidus if you can borrow and/or buy the video from her. just don't tell her i sent you. she thinks i'm nuts, so she probably won't listen to anything you tell her.

sweetpotatopie said...

hey griffinrider thanx for this piece of info. anywho i got sssooo much work, test... i can gop on forever!!! anyway i am ssssooo bored can anyone give me any advice or suggestions of what to do? besides putting a rubber band on the tip of your nose, chewing/sucking on a spoon, eatting, making a fool of myself.... also i don't do hyperness, activiness, and resting actibities. what if i don't do any of these stuff what do i do? am i going senial? did i become that from school work or useing all my brain cells on this blog... did i go insain or not? i am really confused now what is goping on? the whole world is spinning now boy i am getting dizzy. anyway i gotta go to bed.. or do i? this is a mystery...

griffinrider said...

HEY, SPP:
here's some advice: stopping spinning around in circles with your body bent over and your hand touching your nose! of course you're dizzy if you keep doing that!
also, here's a cure for anything in the world:
keep going on this absolutley fantastic blog. thank you for your cooperation.

sweetpotatopie said...

your welcome! any time but i found a better cure sleep!!!

griffinrider said...

here's an even better cure for anything (besides stomachaches): chocolate bars. preferably with caramel.